the glass house philosopher
a philosophical notebook
my philosophical life
Geoffrey Klempner Director of Studies, International Society for Philosophers
There is a persistent memory from my childhood I could not have been more than six or seven holding my head in my hands on the stairs, in a swoon. I date this as the time I first became aware of the world around me as a world. Our house, the street, the suburbs of London, the Earth and sky spread endlessly out to the stars.
As my head spun, I had a fleeting memory image of a girl with blue eyes and black hair, standing in front of a school desk holding a large square piece of red paper. We used a lot of coloured paper at school. Cutting it, sticking it, folding it into models. I have never been able to discover the true connection between the image and the feeling of a world revolving dizzyingly around me. Was it maybe the panicked thought that everything, the world, myself included, is just made of different coloured stuff?
Ten years later, I was doing chemistry experiments in the bathroom. I filled jam jars with poisonous green chlorine gas. Pouring concentrated sulphuric acid on white sugar crystals produced a smoking column of black carbon. Purple potassium permanganate mixed gingerly with magnesium powder made a mixture that exploded with a satisfying white flash.
I wanted to take the world to pieces and see how it worked, and chemistry seemed the best way at any rate, it was the most accessible way to do it. Then I went to university and discovered that chemistry was really about learning endless equations. I was always a lazy student. If I had persisted past the initial hurdles, I might have had a rewarding career as a scientist. Instead, I dropped out at the end of my first year.
I discovered the academic subject 'Philosophy' by accident a couple of years later. I was working as a photographer's assistant in a studio off Oxford Street, in the West End of London. My boss had briefly taken on a second assistant, who'd offered his services for free for the sake of the experience. In a memorable lunch time conversation Simon (let's call him that, I don't remember his name) told me that if I ever thought of going back to university, I must on no account do philosophy. It had been the most miserable three years of his life. This prompted me to investigate. With the certainty we only have when we are young, I knew that whatever Simon was, I was the opposite.
I discovered that philosophy and I were made for one another. It was a whirlwind romance. I revered Kant and idolized Plato. I went on endless philosophical walks. Instead of my beloved camera, I carried a notebook. In October 1972, I enrolled as an undergraduate at Birkbeck College London. From day one, I had set my heart on becoming an academic philosopher.
What went wrong?
To write a satisfactory CV. I would have to account for twenty-seven years devoting my time to philosophy. I got my first class bachelor's degree in 1976, and my doctorate from Oxford in 1982. I had a book published, Naive Metaphysics, in 1994. I did some regular university teaching. There is a shelf in my study three feet long containing everything I wrote between 1972 and 1995. A few million words. I'd happily burn all of it, it is of no consequence now. My philosophical life began with Pathways. Before that, everything is a blur.
My reading of Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance as a second year undergraduate was my most important influence, and the turning point of my life. I could never again look at the professors of philosophy with the respect and reverence I had done before.
What struck me most forcefully about Pirsig's book was his passionate defence of the Greek Sophists. With hindsight, I can now see that Pirsig (or, rather, his alter ego Phaedrus) had been over-zealous in his attack on Plato and Aristotle. Battling against what he saw as a perniciously one-sided vision, in which the dubious character of the sophist was contrasted with the impeccable virtue of the philosopher, it was easy to fall into the opposite extreme. Then again, there is more to philosophy than seeing every side of the question. That is something Marx saw.
In the long history of philosophy, it is only over a comparatively short period that the universities have been the torch bearers for philosophy. Most of the great philosophers were not academics. That is surely sufficient grounds to raise a question.
I am one of a new breed. Call us the Internet Sophists. Whether more will follow our example, only time will tell. I believe the university departments have had their day. Time has come for a more democratic arrangement. The world wide web offers a paradigm for a radically new approach to teaching and publishing. Whether the universities like it or not, the changes have already begun. If they want to survive, it is time to get on board.
19th August 1999
'Tropical House Kew Gardens' © Geoffrey Klempner 1971
'Window' © Geoffrey Klempner 1999
'Geoffrey Klempner Portrait' © June Wynter 1986